Teaser Image

qnoid

Markos Charatzas - London, UK




Decided to do a talk about OO; but this time wanted to provide some actual metrics to back it up.

Took measurements per "iteration", e.g. when a new functionality is added in the code base. For each iteration counted methods and types respectively.

Though in the beginning adding types has some overhead, it only takes 3 iterations to achieve 83% reusability. For reusability counted the number of types reused vs the total number.

Would be interesting to do some more metrics and find how many iterations should take (on average) and how many types to find a true golden ratio and what that is. However it might be the case that numbers vary greatly depending on the problem domain.

An IDE plugin to show you how the reusability ratio increases as you add types would be a great tool to assist developers and give a new dynamic on coding.

Even though when starting to write code we have a higher level of understanding of the problem (iterations are not that short), usually as developers we take the procedural route and think in terms of methods. It demonstrates how complex the object oriented programming paradigm is, even though it has been around for decades.

Resist the urge to jump straight to code. Lay down your thoughts first using pen and paper and start thinking in terms of objects, there are benefits both in the short and long term.

Source

Note On the 3rd iteration there are actually 5 methods. (not 4 as depicted on the slide)

Further Reading

Urban Legends - O is for Object (Part 1)

The Myth - O is for Object (Part 2)

Revelations - O is for Object (Part 3)

On Reusability (Part 1) - Misconceptions

On Reusability (Part 2) - Misconceptions

Don't Lose Your Train of Thoughts series

iterations

methods

//1st iteration
private List<String> load() 
public String findByValue(String value)

//2nd iteration
public String findByReverse(String reverse)

//3rd iteration
private List<Integer> load() 
public Integer findByValue(Integer value)

types

//1st iteration
public final class Service<T> 
public interface Predicate<T> 
public final class Implementation

//2nd iteration
public final class Evals 
public interface Eval<T>

//3rd iteration
public final class PredicateBuilder<T>